- Anything Else -

Gideon et al -- A Question?

You've challenged us to prove the existence of God apart from belief. I'll reverse the challenge to you or to anyone else: Without using faith or testimony, prove that atoms exist.

Follow Ups:

• Please define 'God'. Deep Dad Nine January 16 19100 (8)
  • np Piper January 17 19100 (7)
    • How can you prove or disprove an assertion about an undefined object? Deep Dad Nine January 19 19100 (6)
      • defining god Piper January 19 19100 (5)
        • I Am. Deep Dad Nine January 19 19100 (4)
          • sufficiently deep probe? Piper January 20 19100 (3)
            • It ought to be. Deep Dad Nine January 20 19100 (2)
              • It is (now you have explained it). Piper January 21 19100 (1)
                • Atheism is NOT a disbelief in Jehova. Deep Dad Nine January 23 19100 (0)
• I'll assume I'm an et al Floyd Darwin Fan Club Cascadia Libre! January 15 19100 (4)
  • what actually exists may one day be recognized as something different. Gotch January 18 19100 (2)
    • and what about what doesn't exist? Floyd Darwin Fan Club Cascadia Libre! January 19 19100 (0)
    • Going over old ground again. Gideon Hallett UK January 18 19100 (0)
  • realism v. instrumentalism The Red Cardinal January 16 19100 (0)
• Define your criteria, Gotch. Gideon Hallett UK January 13 19100 (8)
  • Are you sure these are atoms? Deep Dad Nine January 16 19100 (5)
    • Subject to observational caveats, yes, they are. Gideon Hallett UK January 16 19100 (4)
      • So, the question is, are atoms real? Gotch January 18 19100 (3)
        • Is anything real - and can you prove it? Gideon Hallett UK January 18 19100 (2)
          • here's is where I take my next step and put it into faith. Gotch January 18 19100 (1)
            • Gotch, we've been through all of this before. Twice... Gideon Hallett UK January 19 19100 (0)
  • Merely demonstrating a point. Gotch January 14 19100 (1)
    • You missed my point, Gotch Gideon Hallett UK January 14 19100 (0)