- Capitalism and Alternatives -

Re: Sur l'autre main

Posted by: Krasny ( Internationale, All Countries... ) on January 24, 19100 at 10:07:17:

In Reply to: Sur l'autre main posted by bill on January 23, 19100 at 11:48:41:

: For a more "nuanced" view try:

: http://www.prospect-magazine.co.uk/highlights/black_red/

: Or especially:

: http://www.linguafranca.com/br/9911/shatz.html

: ....which points out some flawed scholarship - such as:

: "Unfortunately, Werth and Margolin's contributions are the exception. The trouble with The Black Book of Communism does not end with the introduction. While there is no denying the atrocities visited on the victims of Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot, the book's treatment of communism in Latin America is so one-sided that it might as well be plucked from a U.S. State Department report. We are given the total count of war victims in Sandinista Nicaragua, but we are not told that most of those deaths were caused by the U.S.-funded contras, referred to here as the
: "anti-Sandinista resistance."

: Well...ya gotta reach 100 million somehow...

*That was one of the main criticisms of the *contributers* to the book... that the Eternal Asshole Courtois was obsessed with reaching a figure of 100 million. In fact, Margolin and Werth have both scuttled plans for another book with Courtois believing that he deliberately manipulated and misrepresented their findings in order to make that 100-million-figure-splash.* --K

Follow Ups:


The Debating Room Post a Followup