- Capitalism and Alternatives -

Don't dare disagree with the great Gee

Posted by: Samuel Day Fassbinder ( Citizens against Pedantic Fools, USA ) on July 19, 1999 at 19:04:36:

In Reply to: disagreement grades an F posted by Gee on July 16, 1999 at 03:13:03:

: : SDF: Please move there. If CO2 is our friend, then the more the merrier, and Venus has all you want.

: Glad you perceive that talking about CO2 doing this or that in isolation is nonsense, both ways.

: :be such child's play that I used the same technique on a few pages of THE ULTIMATE RESOURCE II chosen at random and found Simon's text to be describable as complete nonsense.

: Oh well if you found it then it must be right. Daly makes a huge leap from is (entropy) to ought, that is his error.

SDF: "The tidal wave is coming -- we ought to run!"
Gee: "That is in error -- making a huge leap from is to ought."

SDF: BTW, you still have yet to enumerate every use of petroleum in modern society, as per the first part of the assignment.

Follow Ups:

The Debating Room Post a Followup