- Capitalism and Alternatives -

This myth is just another attempt to demonise the English

Posted by: Darcy Carter ( UK ) on February 22, 19100 at 10:17:21:

In Reply to: The good old land league. posted by Lark on February 21, 19100 at 12:00:35:

: : Sorry, here is the complete link. I haven't read it but I thought some folks here would appreciate it.

: The Land War in Ireland is an example of how an unorganised but popular violent struggle can really scare the ruling and imperial classes shitless, I do enjoy the characturisations of the Irish rebels from around about then, not because I'm not aware of the seriousness of the matter (the Irish Famine was, if not artifically created, then artificially maintained and comparable to the Jewish Holocaust if you ask me), but because at the base of it is the idea the irish are stupid, the ruling and imperial classes wherent saying that in 1920 when they where negotiating a withdrawal.

---------As I understood it, there were many offers to help the Irish from various sources in England. These were almost universally obstructed by the Irish landowners who were concerned to maintain the high prices domestic food was fetching due to the famine.

Can you really imagine that the English would attempt genocide against the Irish - with what motive? This myth is just another attempt to demonise the English and the comparison with the holocaust is offensive. Not least to the victime of that crime. The work "genocide" is now bandied around so loosley that it is loosing its true meaning.

Follow Ups:

The Debating Room Post a Followup