- Capitalism and Alternatives -

And the point is?

Posted by: Stoller on October 27, 1999 at 18:14:00:

In Reply to: How Trotskyites differ from Leninists... posted by Frenchy on October 27, 1999 at 10:34:20:

: Most people will not have heard of the Workers World Party, which, according to Cockburn, is the organization that has put together this new "anti-war" coalition. But I remember them from the sixties as the only Trotskyist splinter to endorse the Soviet invasion of Hungary in 1956... (From National Review, February 25, 1991.)
Note the words the only Trotskyist splinter..., then ask yourself: Were there more than one 'Trotskyite' group? If so, were their policies different?
Then ask yourself: Who on this debate board is supporting some obscure tendency from 30 years ago?
Straw man.
As William S. Burroughs put it: 'You win something like jellyfish, meester.'

Follow Ups:

To obscure socialist history in favor of accuracy. Frenchy October 28 1999 (32)
- The Dope on Burroughs (or Talkin' Modern Literature with Frenchy) Stoller October 31 1999 (1)
  - Gimme a break, it's junk. Frenchy November 01 1999 (0)
- trotskyists are leninists... Red Deathy Socialist Party UK October 29 1999 (10)
  - ...with an exception or two... Stoller November 05 1999 (0)
  - Oh...I remember it well. bill October 31 1999 (0)
  - Why, thank you and a hat tip sir. Frenchy October 31 1999 (7)
    - Slight and few. Red Deathy Socialist Party UK November 01 1999 (6)
      - Great post! Samuel Day Fassbinder Citizens for Mustard Greens USA November 05 1999 (0)
      - EP Thompson was a Leninist? Lark November 03 1999 (1)
        
        Aye. Red Deathy Socialist Party UK November 05 1999 (0)
      - But once in power Frenhy November 03 1999 (2)
        
        It's a disgusting distortion. Lark November 03 1999 (1)
        
        'disgusting distortions', a revolting development. Frenchy November 05 1999 (0)
- Hiding depravity Stuart Gort USA October 28 1999 (18)
  - Flogging a dead horse Stoller October 28 1999 (13)
    - You may not think that there is any truth to be drawn from that statement. Frenchy October 29 1999 (12)
      - Starving is a Blessing? Quincunx October 29 1999 (11)
        
        Nope, a job is a Blessing. Frenchy October 29 1999 (10)
        
        Bless you. Grandpa Tired Old Workers from the Old Days October 31 1999 (2)
        
        Striking capital. borg November 03 1999 (0)
        
        Thanks Gramps, you make my point as well as... Frenchy November 03 1999 (0)
        
        A good thing. Stuart Gort USA October 29 1999 (6)
        
        A good thing---for who? pOEM October 31 1999 (0)
        
        Good Things. Dr. Cruel October 31 1999 (0)
        
        A job can be a blessing in disguise. Frenchy October 31 1999 (0)
        
        A good thing that helps rationalize exploitation Quincunx October 31 1999 (2)
        
        Qx et al. just happen to be superior human beings Frenchy November 03 1999 (1)
        
        Don't mean to step on your (ranting) groove... Stoller November 05 1999 (0)
  - My 'motivations' Nikhil Jaikumar Americans in Solidarity with the Sandinistas MA, USA October 28 1999 (3)
    - Houses do not grow on trees Dr. Cruel October 31 1999 (0)
    - how does taking my money and giving it to him create a better society? Frenchy October 31 1999 (1)
      - I'm scared Nikhil Jaikumar DSA MA, USA November 01 1999 (0)
The point. Dr. Cruel October 28 1999 (0)